Chapter 1: The Ongoing Debate Surrounding Homo Naledi

The discourse regarding Homo naledi and its burial practices is far from settled. Recent research suggests that this relative of Homo sapiens may not have engaged in the practice of burying their dead. Several scientists have raised questions about the validity of the claims made by their peers.

This paragraph will result in an indented block of text, typically used for quoting other text.

Section 1.1: Evolving Understanding of Human Evolution

Our comprehension of human evolution continues to adapt as new findings come to light. Discoveries are revealing more about the migration patterns of our ancestors and their day-to-day existence. Some of these revelations have been particularly surprising, as seen earlier this year.

A study led by Professor Lee Berger from the University of the Witwatersrand proposed that Homo naledi, which existed around 300,000 years ago, engaged in burial practices and adorned graves with abstract symbols. Remarkably, it was suggested that the small size of their brains, comparable to that of chimpanzees, did not preclude this behavior. Yet, the question remains: Did Homo naledi truly practice burial before Homo sapiens?

Skepticism regarding these claims is widespread. The scientific community has expressed doubt about this so-called “revolutionary” discovery from the outset. Issues arose, particularly because Professor Berger’s team did not invite outside experts to evaluate the evidence gathered from the Rising Star cave system in South Africa. Additionally, the findings were publicized prior to undergoing peer review, raising concerns about their credibility. Critics contend that reviews were unanimous in deeming the evidence insufficient, leaning towards the idea that the remains found were not deliberately buried but rather deposited by chance. This is suggested by the dispersed nature of the bones within the cave, indicating a lack of intentional burial practices.

Section 1.2: Controversial Findings and Theories

How did the remains of at least 15 Homo naledi individuals end up in the cave? The authors of the recent study propose two potential scenarios. One possibility is that these hominids intentionally transported and buried the remains in the cave. Alternatively, natural elements might have played a role, such as water carrying the bodies into the cave. It's important to note that Berger and his team did not follow the fundamental principles of archaeothanatology, which involve ruling out natural processes as an explanation.

Researchers argue that natural movements of the bones present a more plausible explanation than the idea of the cave serving as an intentional burial site. Furthermore, the authors state that Berger's team has yet to apply any dating methods to the supposed ritualistic markings. Nevertheless, their study claims that the rock engravings found at the site were created by Homo naledi between 335,000 and 241,000 years ago.

Taking into account these inconsistencies, the authors assert that there is "no compelling scientific evidence" to support the assertion that H. naledi practiced burial or created rock art within the Rising Star cave system.

Chapter 2: Insights into Homo Naledi’s Existence

Homo naledi was identified in the Rising Star cave system in 2013, a site regarded by scientists as a critical location in the study of human origins in Africa. This species exhibits anatomical traits that align it with other members of the Homo genus, including similarities in jaw and foot structure. However, certain characteristics like the pelvis, shoulder girdle, and thigh bone bear resemblance to Australopithecus. Current simulations suggest that Homo naledi individuals stood approximately 150 cm tall and weighed around 45 kg.

The timeline of when Homo naledi existed remains ambiguous. Research from 2017 suggests that they lived during the Pleistocene epoch, with fossil evidence indicating a timeframe between 236,000 and 335,000 years ago.

In the video titled "Homo Naledi Burial? A Public Peer Review of the Evidence #RealArchaeology," experts delve into the controversial claims surrounding the burial practices of Homo naledi and the implications of these findings.

Another insightful video, "Groundbreaking New Discoveries! Homo Naledi Burials & Engraved Cave Art," discusses the latest discoveries related to Homo naledi and their potential burial rituals and art.

Attention all readers!

As content creators on Medium.com, we face minimal compensation for our hard work. If you find value in my articles, please consider supporting me on my “Buy Me a Coffee” page. Your small contributions can make a big difference in fueling my passion for creating quality content. Thank you for your support!