Recognizing Stereotypes in Our Judgments

Have you ever paused to consider your own tendencies to categorize others? It can be quite an eye-opener. Recently, acquaintances remarked on how well-prepared I was for an outdoor gathering. When I shared my experience as a former long-distance backpacker, their surprise was palpable.

This kind of misjudgment is something I've grown used to over the years. Perhaps my smaller stature contributes to this. Time and again, I’ve heard comments like, “You don’t seem like the person who would:

…hike to the bottom of the Grand Canyon and back up.” In reality, I’ve accomplished that feat six times.

Or, “You don’t look like someone who would enjoy barrel racing.” Yet, in my twenties, I participated in amateur barrel racing on swift horses.

Or, “You wouldn’t travel alone to Europe.” Ironically, I had no choice but to do so on multiple business trips, which forced me to confront my insecurities about language, food, currency, customs, and more.

Or, “You couldn’t possibly ride 300 miles on a motorcycle.” But I’ve done that too.

We all have a tendency to stereotype based on first impressions—whether it’s someone’s appearance, tone of voice, companions, or even their vehicle. I find myself doing this as well.

Stereotyping is a quick form of judgment that often leads us to believe we know everything about a person, even before we’ve exchanged a single word. How mistaken we can be.

I remember when a new colleague joined my department, and my immediate reaction was negativity. I viewed him as loud, arrogant, and bothersome. However, as I got to know Tony better, I learned to appreciate him beyond his quirks, and we eventually became friends at work.

Our comfort zones often lead us to surround ourselves with people who mirror our aspirations, styles, and attitudes. Those on the rise tend to look down on those satisfied with the status quo, which results in us mentally pigeonholing individuals into narrow categories. This habit creates unnecessary barriers.

This issue appears in various aspects of life—neighborhoods, schools, job interviews, and even in Hollywood. For example, many American spy films portray all Russians as adversaries, but I’ve visited Russia and understand that there’s a vast difference between its citizens’ beliefs and those of their government.

During my college years, I was astonished to discover that sorority members would scrutinize the brand labels on the jackets of potential new members during rush events.

Similarly, when I mention my Christian faith, people often jump to conclusions about my political views, lifestyle, or writing topics. In truth, Christians are a highly diverse group.

Racial assumptions also persist. As a white individual, I’ve had people surprised to learn that one of my closest friends is a dark-skinned African American.

My roots trace back to Poland, and I grew up in a community where ethnic stereotypes were prevalent, often suggesting that Polish people lacked intelligence. We are bombarded with stereotypes from a young age, making them hard to discard.

Prejudices still exist regarding age differences in dating, stereotypes about hair color, and generalizations about musicians, Ivy League graduates, accountants, and even nationalities.

While my reflections on these issues may not change the world, I hope they prompt readers to consider, “Am I quick to judge someone? Could I be mistaken? Does this individual or group merit a deeper understanding from me?”

The answer is often a resounding “Yes.”

It’s valuable for each of us to take a step back and reassess our biases.

Did you know you can receive my articles by email whenever I publish?