Iceland's Volcanic Mysteries: Earthquakes Without Eruptions—So Far
Written on
Chapter 1: Understanding Iceland's Seismic Activity
In recent times, southwestern Iceland, known for its geothermal marvels, has experienced sporadic lava flows from several fissures, raising alarms about a possible eruption. On October 25, 2023, over 1,000 earthquakes were recorded within a 24-hour span on the Reykjanes Peninsula, stirring questions about the timing and location of a potential significant eruption. Following a large evacuation of Grindavík, home to more than 3,500 residents, concerns mounted. However, the seismic activity has since diminished, leaving both the local population and scientists grappling with the uncertainties of this volatile situation.
The role of volcanoes in the carbon cycle and their transient climatic effects raises the question: How crucial is the recent unusual seismic activity in Iceland?
Volcanic Activity Explained
When envisioning volcanic eruptions, one often pictures a mountain erupting with lava. While Iceland has such volcanoes, the Reykjanes Peninsula is characterized by fissure eruptions. These occur when cracks in the ground unexpectedly open, allowing magma to force its way to the surface. Unlike traditional volcanoes, these fissure eruptions often occur without clear warnings, complicating predictions about where the next eruption might take place.
The geological activity in this region began in 2020, with magma accumulating underground in the Reykjanes Peninsula. This led to three minor eruptions occurring in 2021, 2022, and July 2023, in a peculiar rhythm approximately 320 days apart. These eruptions originated from closely situated fissures near the isolated Fagradalsfjall mountain, filling uninhabited valleys with rivers of molten rock about 10 kilometers east of current activities. While these events were celebrated by Icelanders as a testament to their geologically vibrant country, the increasing size of the dike and the rapid pace of developments now pose an imminent threat to Grindavík and the nearby geothermal power plant.
The recent unrest commenced on October 25, 2023, marked by a spike in minor earthquakes north of Grindavík. GPS and satellite radar data indicated ground uplift at an alarming rate of 7 centimeters, suggesting magma intrusion beneath Fagradalsfjall into a 15-kilometer-long crack in the Earth’s crust, known as a dike. This increased seismic activity has resulted in cracked roads and subsiding ground, prompting the evacuation of Grindavík on November 10.
Freysteinn Sigmundsson, a volcanologist at the University of Iceland in Reykjavík, notes, "What is different now is that the dike is larger, and things happened much faster."
As of November 24, around 650 earthquakes were recorded near the dike intrusion. Most were below M1.0, with the highest reaching M2.7. Interestingly, seismic activity tends to decrease prior to an eruption, indicating that much of the tectonic stress has been alleviated. This aligns with historical patterns observed before previous eruptions.
Section 1.1: The Mystery of Magma
As scientists monitor the situation closely, a pressing question arises: Why, after such intense movement, is the magma now seemingly stagnant? Will this unrest lead to an eruption?
Iceland's volcanic activity can be attributed to its position above a plume of molten rock and at the junction of the North American and Eurasian tectonic plates. The current activity is not anticipated to be as catastrophic as the 2010 Eyjafjallajökull eruption, as the magma beneath the Reykjanes Peninsula has low viscosity, significantly reducing the risk of explosive eruptions.
The recent changes in activity are thought to be part of a prolonged period of fissure eruptions, beginning with the 2021 eruption, which saw a three-week gap between the magma's subsurface invasion and the eruption itself. This pattern mirrors conditions observed 800 years ago when lava flowed into what is now the outskirts of Reykjavík. However, the relationship between the Fagradalsfjall and Svartsengi magmatic systems remains ambiguous, with ongoing debates about their possible connections at depth.
Chapter 2: The Challenges of Volcanic Prediction
Forecasting volcanic eruptions presents a significant challenge in volcanology. While considerable progress has been made in understanding Earth's magmatic depths, accurately predicting eruption style, timing, and location remains uncertain. Unlike meteorological forecasts, which can be relatively precise in the short term, volcanic predictions are complicated by the hidden nature of volcanic activity until it manifests.
Icelandic volcanologists employ various instruments to monitor volcanic activity, including GPS and satellite radar for tracking ground changes and gas sensors for detecting emissions like sulfur dioxide from magma. Real-time earthquake detection is facilitated through repurposed fiber-optic communication cables. Additionally, scientists are collecting volcanic gas samples from magma located 2 kilometers deep using boreholes at geothermal facilities.
To prepare for potential scenarios, scientists utilize lava-flow models to analyze the movement and cooling of lava, critical for identifying areas needing protective measures.
Section 2.1: Volcanic Eruptions and Climate Change
Volcanoes serve as Earth's climate regulators, affecting both long and short-term climate patterns. While they contribute significantly to the carbon cycle over geological timescales, short-term eruptions can have noteworthy but temporary climatic effects. This connection to climate change arises from their release of CO2 and other gases into the atmosphere.
However, the reality is stark: human activities overshadow the impact of volcanoes on the carbon cycle by a factor of more than 100. For example, in 2010, human activities emitted 35 gigatons (Gt) of CO2, while volcanoes produced between 0.13 to 0.44 Gt—80 to 270 times less.
Even a major eruption like Mount St. Helens in 1980, which expelled 10 million tons of CO2 in just 9 hours, pales in comparison to human emissions, which match this output in a mere 2.5 hours. Not even the explosive Hunga Tonga-Hunga Ha'apai eruption could be blamed for current high temperatures, as it likely had a cooling effect on the climate system. Large explosive eruptions are rare, occurring globally every decade, whereas human emissions continue to rise annually.
In summary, volcanic activity in Iceland is a minor concern compared to the pressing issues caused by human reliance on fossil fuels, which jeopardize livelihoods, socio-economic development, and ecosystems. For every dollar spent on climate action, five times that amount is funneled into fossil fuel subsidies, exacerbating the problem. The need for a transformative shift away from fossil fuels is urgent and undeniable.
The residents of Grindavík are being shielded from volcanic dangers through evacuations and the construction of protective walls around the Svartsengi geothermal plant. However, globally, the threats are different—rising sea levels, hurricanes, and wildfires are pressing issues. The world must confront these challenges head-on, as building barriers against them is not straightforward.
The path forward requires a historic economic transformation to abandon fossil fuels and prioritize sustainable practices. The detrimental effects of fossil fuel dependency on climate goals and the planet are clear, and the fossil fuel industry continues to expand this divide.
It's time to raise our voices in urgency.